Ask for feedback against a clear standard
A first draft may need help with its argument, while a nearly finished page may need a clarity check. Choose the level of feedback before requesting line edits. Provide the assignment, brief, or intended audience when it affects the assessment.
A simple rubric can cover purpose, structure, evidence, and expression. Ask for one passage that illustrates each important problem so the feedback stays connected to the actual draft.
Turn a comment into a revision decision
“This is unclear” does not tell you what to do. A useful critique identifies the passage, explains the reader’s likely confusion, and suggests a specific kind of change. You can then decide whether that suggestion serves your goal.
Ask the reviewer to distinguish an objective inconsistency from a stylistic preference. A date mismatch needs correction; a preference for shorter sentences may need discussion.
Revise the largest problem first
Fix missing reasoning and poor sequence before polishing every sentence. Otherwise you may spend time editing paragraphs that later need to be removed. After structural changes, return for a narrower pass on clarity and tone.
Keep your own judgment. Feedback can miss context or prefer a generic style. Accept the changes you can justify, then read the revised draft as a whole.
A few useful answers.
How should I ask AI to critique my writing?+
Specify the audience and purpose, name two or three evaluation criteria, and ask for comments tied to exact passages.
Should I accept every suggestion?+
No. Check whether it identifies a real problem and whether the proposed change preserves your meaning and voice.
How is critique different from rewriting?+
Critique explains what may need changing and why. Rewriting supplies alternative wording. Feedback is useful when you want to make the edit yourself.
Sources & further reading
Public reference pages reviewed October 16, 2026. Product examples are not a hands-on ranking.
HyperWrite — Writing Critique AI ↗